Arachin 4b ~ The Tumtum, the Androgyne, and the Fluidity of Gender

ערכין ד,ב

זכר - ולא טומטום ואנדרוגינוס

“A male” - and not a tumtum or androgyne.

In addition to male and female, the Talmud describes two other gender categories: tumtum and androgynous. The tumtum is a person whose genitalia are somehow hidden or covered, so that it is not known if they are male or female. In contrast, the genitalia of the androgyne (an ancient Greek word formed from ἀνδρός  andros - “man” and γυνή gune, - “woman”) are in plain sight. It just isn’t clear whether they are male or female organs. The two are mentioned on at least twenty-three pages of the Babylonian Talmud, and in no fewer than nine halachot in the Jerusalem Talmud, so let’s figure out what, from a medical perspective, they are.

The Tumtum

There is no ambiguity about the gender of a tumtum. We just need to get a glimpse of the genitals. (The eleventh century dictionary known as the Aruch connects the word tumtum with the word atum (אטום), meaning sealed.) The problem is that the genitals are covered by what is usually described as skin. Once this cover is surgically opened, the gender will be revealed. In fact according to Rav Ammi (Yevamot 64a), both Abraham and Sarah were each a tumtum. Yes, you read that correctly. Each had genitalia that were hidden. Rav Ammi suggests this as an explanation as to why the couple were infertile for so many years. Once the covering had been removed the couple could then procreate as normal, and along came Isaac.

אמר רבי אמי אברהם ושרה טומטמין היו שנאמר (ישעיהו נא, א) הביטו אל צור חוצבתם ואל מקבת בור נוקרתם וכתיב (ישעיהו נא, ב) הביטו אל אברהם אביכם ואל שרה תחוללכם

Rabbi Ami said: Abraham and Sarah were originally tumtumin, as it is stated: “Look to the rock from where you were hewn, and to the hole of the pit from where you were dug” (Isaiah 51:1), and it is written in the next verse: “Look to Abraham your father and to Sarah who bore you” (Isaiah 51:2),

רשי:

חוצבתם - נעשה לו זכרות: “Hewn”: He was made into a male

נוקרתם - נעשה לה נקבות : “From where you were dug” which made here a female

Urologists have yet to identify this syndrome.

Screen Shot 2019-06-17 at 2.31.21 PM.png

The Androgyne

In 1797 the physician James Parsons, published a book which he dedicated to the Royal Society of London, of which he was a Fellow: “ A Mechanical and Critical Inquiry into the Nature of Hermaphrodites.” Parsons noted that the Romans “had laws made against their Androgyni [which were] remarkably severe; for whensoever a child was reputed one of these, his sentence was to be shut up in a chest alive, and thrown into the sea…

Parsons was not only well-read in Roman law; he cited the fourth chapter of the Mishnah in Bikkurim, which contains a list of the ways in which the androgne sometimes resembles a man, and sometimes a woman:

ביכורים פרק ד

כֵּיצַד שָׁוֶה לַאֲנָשִׁים: מְטַמֵּא בְּלֹבֶן כַּאֲנָשִׁים, וְזוֹקֵק לְיִבּוּם כַּאֲנָשִׁים, וּמִתְעַטֵּף וּמִסְתַּפֵּר כַּאֲנָשִׁים, וְנוֹשֵׂא אֲבָל לֹא נִשָּׂא כַּאֲנָשִׁים, וְחַיָּב בְּכָל מִצְוֹת הָאֲמוּרוֹת בַּתּוֹרָה כַּאֲנָשִׁים:

In what ways is the andogyne like men?…He dresses like men; He can take a wife but not be taken as a wife, like men. [When he is born] his mother counts the blood of purification, like men; He may not be secluded with women, like men. He is not maintained with the daughters, like men…And he must perform all the commandments of the Torah, like men.

כֵּיצַד שָׁוֶה לַנָּשִׁים: מְטַמֵּא בְּאֹדֶם כַּנָּשִׁים, וְאֵינוֹ מִתְיַחֵד עִם הָאֲנָשִׁים כַּנָּשִׁים, וְאֵינוֹ עוֹבֵר עַל "בַּל תַּקִּיף" וְלֹא עַל "בַּל תַּשְׁחִית" וְלֹא עַל "בַּל תְּטַמֵּא לַמֵּתִים" כַּנָּשִׁים, וּפָסוּל מִן הָעֵדוּת כַּנָּשִׁים, וְאֵינוֹ נִבְעַל בַּעֲבֵירָה כַּנָּשִׁים, וְנִפְסַל מִן הַכְּהֻנָּה כַּנָּשִׁים:

And in what ways is he like women?… he must not be secluded with men, like women; And he doesn’t make his brother’s wife liable for yibbum (levirate marriage); And he does not share [in the inheritance] with the sons, like women; And he cannot eat most holy sacrifices, like women…. he is disqualified from being a witness, like women…

The Androgyne & Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia

Ambiguous genitalia in neonates. From here.

Ambiguous genitalia in neonates. From here.

One of the most common causes of androgyny is congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH), caused by a mutation in the CYP21 gene. The adrenal glands, which sits atop the kidneys, are where the action takes place. They produce androgens, which are then converted into the potent sex hormone testosterone. In most (95%) cases of CAH, there is a deficiency of the enzyme 21-hydroxylase. As a result, the adrenal glands produce excessive amounts of the virilizing hormone androgen. (It also causes severe salt wasting, which can be very dangerous, but we are not getting into that now. And there are different severities of the syndrome, but you’ve got a limited attention span, so we will keep it simple.) This excessive androgen production does very little in (XY) males; their genitalia look normal. But in genetic (XX) baby girls the androgens affect the external genitalia and they may become ambiguous: the clitoris becomes enlarged, sometimes to the degree that it resembles a penis. In very severe cases the baby girl has what appears to be an empty scrotum, and may be raised as a boy, all the while being an XX girl with CAH.

Today all newborns are screened for 21-hydroxylase. The deficiency can be treated with hormone replacement, and the genital ambiguity may be corrected, although this latter intervention has, over the last decades, become very controversial.

“Anecdotally, in the Western world most [intersex] babies were raised as female because the genitalia were easier to reconstruct... clinical experience suggests that cultural factors are very influential. This may be no bad thing as there is no ‘right’ medical answer and the child will have to grow up in the community into which it is born.”
— Woodhouse, C.R.J. Intersex Surgery in the Adult. BJU International 2004. 93 (3): 57-65

The androgyne and the hermaphrodite

The Soncino Talmud identifies the androgyne as a hermaphrodite, that is, a person with both male and female genitalia. So does Goldschmidt’s German translation (“der zwitter”). Cases of true hermaphroditism are extremely rare, and there are only a few scattered case reports in the medical literature. (You can read one reported from Sheba Hospital in Tel Aviv here.) Rather than there being two sets, in these cases the genitalia are ambiguous, and although they have both ovarian and testicular tissue the scrotum does not always contain testes.

Alice Dreger, formerly a Professor of Medical Humanities and Bioethics at Northwestern University, (it’s complicated) wrote a terrific (and controversial) book that tackles some of the issues facing intersex people - those who were once called hermaphrodites. In the past, when faced these difficult cases of intersex or ambiguous genders, clinicians focused on what she calls a “gonadal division.” (Since biopsies and genetic sequencing were not available to the rabbis of the Talmud, they, like clinicians, focused on this gonadal division, for what else could they do?) But, she notes,

a system that emphasizes gonadal anatomy above all else suffers from two major deficits. First, it is scientifically questionable, because it relies on the anatomy of the gonads (functioning or not) more than any other considerations. Second, it provides little clinical help, often confusing and harming the patient, and sometimes also the physician.

Instead, she advocates for a description based on etiology and the patient’s needs. “Such an approach would have the salutary effects of improving patient and physician understanding and reducing the biases that are inherent in the use of the current language of 'hermaphroditism'.”

“True hermaphrodites: defined as presenting at least one ovary and at least one testis, or at least one ovotestis...The scientific understanding of sexual development has progressed tremendously in the last 125 years, but the existing taxonomy does not reflect that progress. Scientists and clinicians now recognize that the structure of the gonads does not correlate simply with genotype, phenotype, physiology, diagnosis, or gender identity. The anatomy of testicular tissue in women with androgen insensitivity syndrome (AIS) is quite similar to the anatomy of testicular tissue in non- intersex males, yet their physiologies, phenotypes and gender identities differ markedly.”
— Dreger, A, et al. Changing the Nomenclature/Taxonomy for Intersex. Journal of Pediatric Endocrinology & Metabolism 2005. 18, 729-733

The many Shades of Gender

We are used to think that when an egg carrying an X chromosome meets a sperm carrying an X or Y chromosome, one of two things will happen: a genetic female (46XX) or a genetic male (46XY) with genitalia to match. But in fact it is way more complicated than that. We know that there are at least 14 genes involved in the process of sexual differentiation, and many more will likely be discovered. A mutation or malfunction of any of these has a dramatic effect on the process of gender differentiation. For example if there is a defect in the enzymes involved in producing testosterone, there may be ambiguous external genitalia; deficiency of the enzyme 5α-reductase results in variable degrees of under-masculinized external genitalia and genital ambiguity; individuals with partial androgen insensitivity syndrome may also have ambiguous genitalia, and there is no consensus regarding an optimal sex of rearing them; and newborns with congenital adrenal hyperplasia, may have male appearing genitalia while all the time being 46XX.

We have previously noted the strange effects of yet gene discovered in the 1980s. This sex-determining gene on a tiny bit of the male Y chromosome is called the sry gene. That gene tells the body to develop into a male or female appearing body. Sometimes the sry gene sneaks off of the Y gene and makes its way into the DNA of an XX female. As a result, she will develop male anatomy while genetically remaining an XX female. (Please read that sentence again, just to be sure you have understood it.) And sometimes the sry gene on an XY genetic male can mutate and not work. In that case, the genetic male appears to have the organs of a female, which is what occurs in Swyer syndrome. (You can hear more about the amazing sex-changing effects of sry in this fascinating podcast.)

And then there is the small community in the Dominican Republic where there have been a number of cases in which little girls grow a penis and turn into little boys. These observations were first reported to the scientific community in 1974, and are caused by a deficiency of the steroid 5α-reductase. Here is how the BBC explained what is going on when they reported about it in 2015.

When you are conceived you normally have a pair of X chromosomes if you are to become a girl and a set of XY chromosomes if you are destined to be male. For the first weeks of life in womb you are neither…Then, around eight weeks after conception, the sex hormones kick in. If you're genetically male the Y chromosome instructs your gonads to become testicles and sends testosterone to a structure called the tubercle, where it is converted into a more potent hormone called dihydro-testosterone. This in turn transforms the tubercle into a penis. If you're female and you don't make dihydro-testosterone then your tubercle becomes a clitoris…the reason [some genetic males] don't have male genitalia when they are born is because they are deficient in an enzyme called 5-alpha-reductase, which normally converts testosterone into dihydro-testosterone.

So the boys, despite having an XY chromosome, appear female when they are born. At puberty, like other boys, they get a second surge of testosterone. This time the body does respond and they sprout muscles, testes and a penis.

So gender identity is very complicated. James Parsons, that physician who wrote the book on hermaphrodites in 1797 tackled some of the difficult questions that were addressed in Mishnah Bikkurim: can a hermaphrodite get married? (yes, but to which gender varies by case); can they be a witness? (only if the “predominating sex” is male); can they be ordained as a minister? (no); The rabbis were puzzled as to the “true” gender of the androgyne, and so classified them as sometimes male, and sometimes female. It was the best they could do at the time, and Parsons, writing 1,500 years later did the same. Thanks to modern medicine we have learned why these intersex cases occur, but as a society we have still a long way to go to help make their lives easier.

Arachin 2~What is life worth?

Today we start a new tractate of Talmud, named Arachin - ערכין. We will read 33 pages answering a question few of us have had to ask: what is a life worth?

Let’s start with the source:

ויקרא 27:2-8

אִישׁ כִּי יַפְלִא נֶדֶר בְּעֶרְכְּךָ נְפָשֹׁת לַיהֹוָה׃

וְהָיָה עֶרְכְּךָ הַזָּכָר מִבֶּן עֶשְׂרִים שָׁנָה וְעַד בֶּן־שִׁשִּׁים שָׁנָה וְהָיָה עֶרְכְּךָ חֲמִשִּׁים שֶׁקֶל כֶּסֶף בְּשֶׁקֶל הַקֹּדֶשׁ׃

וְאִם־נְקֵבָה הִוא וְהָיָה עֶרְכְּךָ שְׁלֹשִׁים שָׁקֶל׃

וְאִם מִבֶּן־חָמֵשׁ שָׁנִים וְעַד בֶּן־עֶשְׂרִים שָׁנָה וְהָיָה עֶרְכְּךָ הַזָּכָר עֶשְׂרִים שְׁקָלִים וְלַנְּקֵבָה עֲשֶׂרֶת שְׁקָלִים׃

וְאִם מִבֶּן־חֹדֶשׁ וְעַד בֶּן־חָמֵשׁ שָׁנִים וְהָיָה עֶרְכְּךָ הַזָּכָר חֲמִשָּׁה שְׁקָלִים כָּסֶף וְלַנְּקֵבָה עֶרְכְּךָ שְׁלֹשֶׁת שְׁקָלִים כָּסֶף׃

וְאִם מִבֶּן־שִׁשִּׁים שָׁנָה וָמַעְלָה אִם־זָכָר וְהָיָה עֶרְכְּךָ חֲמִשָּׁה עָשָׂר שָׁקֶל וְלַנְּקֵבָה עֲשָׂרָה שְׁקָלִים׃

וְאִם־מָךְ הוּא מֵעֶרְכֶּךָ וְהֶעֱמִידוֹ לִפְנֵי הַכֹּהֵן וְהֶעֱרִיךְ אֹתוֹ הַכֹּהֵן עַל־פִּי אֲשֶׁר תַּשִּׂיג יַד הַנֹּדֵר יַעֲרִיכֶנּוּ הַכֹּהֵן׃ 

When anyone explicitly vows to God the equivalent for a human being, the following scale shall apply:

If it is a male from twenty to sixty years of age, the equivalent is fifty shekels of silver by the sanctuary weight; if it is a female, the equivalent is thirty shekels.

If the age is from five years to twenty years, the equivalent is twenty shekels for a male and ten shekels for a female.

If the age is from one month to five years, the equivalent for a male is five shekels of silver, and the equivalent for a female is three shekels of silver.

If the age is sixty years or over, the equivalent is fifteen shekels in the case of a male and ten shekels for a female.

But if someone cannot afford the equivalent, they shall be presented before the priest, and the priest shall make an assessment; the priest shall make the assessment according to what the vower can afford.

Here is a summary:

Fixed valuations (ערכין) in silver shekels
Age Male Female
1 month to 5 years53
5 to 20 years2010
20 to 60 years5030
60 years and over1510

If the vower cannot afford the amount, the priest assesses what he can pay.

These amounts are an estimation of the “value” (whatever that means) of each of these people. About this there is no question. Here is Rashi on verse 2, citing the Sifra:

בערכך נפשת. לִתֵּן עֵרֶךְ נְפָשׁוֹת — לוֹמַר עֵרֶךְ דָּבָר שֶׁנַּפְשׁוֹ תְלוּיָה בוֹ עָלַי

בערכך נפשות — he expressly states that he will give to the Sanctuary the valuation attached to a life by saying, “the payment of the valuation of such and such a thing — that, however, being something upon which its life depends — is incumbent upon me”

And here is Ibn Ezra:

בערכך נפשות. הטעם שידור נדר לאמר אם השם יעשה לי כך אפדה נפשי כדי ערכי או ערך בני או ערך בהמה

Its meaning is, he will take a vow saying: If God will do the following for me then I will redeem my life in accordance with its value, or the value of my son’s life, or the value of the life of a beast.

Note the following:

Age and sex belong to the person valued, not the vower. A youth who vows the value of an elder pays the elder’s rate. A woman who vows a man’s valuer pays the man’s rate.

  • Age is fixed at the moment of the vow. If the subject crosses a threshold before payment, the rate at the time of the vow still applies.

  • Everyone (priests, Levites, Israelites, women and men) can vow an ערך and be the subject of one.

  • Ability to pay belongs to the vower. A poor person who vows the erkh of a rich person pays the poor rate.

  • An ערך payment is never less than one sela or more than fifty sela.

Remember these points; we will return to them below.

How does the talmud’s economic (not moral) value of a life compare to our modern conception? To answer this, we need to take a short dive into…

The 9/11 Compensation Fund

Shortly after the 9/11 terrorist attacks, Congress set up a fund to compensate the families of those murdered. It was called the September 11th Victim Compensation Fund, and was allocated $7.375 billion (including operational and administrative costs). Feinberg initially set the compensation for noneconomic loss at $250,000 for the death of the victim, and $50,000 for each surviving spouse and dependent. He also decided that he needed a “swift, certain and uncomplicated formula” which clearly explained the regulations to estimate individual awards.

As he made clear on multiple occasions, Feinberg didn’t assign a moral or intrinsic worth to anyone. Rather, he valued each victim’s life by what that person would have earned over a normal working life, then added a flat amount for non-economic loss.

How the calculation worked

  • Economic loss: Feinberg said the award was based on what the victim would have earned over a work-life but for 9/11, so a banker, a soldier, a firefighter and a secretary each received a different amount. For example, he calculated Salman Hamdani’s future earnings from the $35,000 a year he made as an entry-level lab assistant.

  • Non-economic loss: Early on, Feinberg decided to give each family, regardless of income, a flat $250,000 for pain and suffering. The final regulations also added $100,000 for each surviving spouse and each surviving child.

  • Offsets: The statute required him to subtract collateral sources of income, such as life insurance, from the economic plus non-economic total. Feinberg described this as a social-welfare safety net, not tort law.

From here.

This impossibly difficult work consumed every waking moment of Feinberg and his team. Family members wanted to be heard, and Feinberg was present as many hearings as possible. By the end of the process he had attended more than 900 of the 1,600 family hearings in person, even flying to London to listen to the families of the British victims of that terrible day. By the time it closed in June 2004, the fund had processed 7,300 claims for death and physical injury arising out of the 9/11 attacks.

We are now ready to compare Arachin to the 9/11 Fund. There are a surprising number of similarities (in green) and important differences (in red).

What is life worth? ערכין compared with the 9/11 Victim Compensation Fund
Point Arakhin 9/11 Fund Comparison
Whose characteristics set the rate Age and sex of the person valued; the vower's own are irrelevant Age at death and dependents of the deceased victim; the filer's own are irrelevant Similar
Sex as a variable Explicit: male and female rates differ Women's work-life set by the all-active-men figure in the military explanation, raising their presumed losses Different
Survivors The vower's family plays no role Spouse and each dependent add $100,000 in noneconomic loss Different
When age is measured Frozen at a legal moment (the vow); later aging is ignored Frozen at a legal moment (date of death); later filing or payment dates are ignored Similar
How age is structured Four fixed brackets with boundary rules Age-specific growth rates (military explanation), moving away from age bands Different
Who may take part Broad: priests, Levites, Israelites, women, slaves Broad: representatives of those killed at three sites, defined by the event, not by class Similar
Limits on participation Carve-outs by capacity and status (tumtum, minors, under one month) Event requirement, plus waiver of the right to sue Different
Whose means count The vower's: a poor vower pays the poor rate The victim's earnings raised the award; the family's insurance and pensions lowered it Different
Does the subject's wealth matter No Yes: presumed tables considered income up to $231,000 (2000), though Feinberg said there was no cap Different
Floor A floor under the lowest case: no payment below one sela A floor under the lowest case: $250,000 noneconomic presumption, with less described as very rare Similar
Ceiling Fifty sela None in law; awards over $8 million Different
Direction of payment The vower pays the Temple The government pays the family Different

Green entries mark similarities; red marks differences. The work-life, age-growth, and income points come from the Special Master's explanation for military victims and may not describe every claim category.

Sources: Mishnah Arakhin 1, 2, 4; 28 CFR 104.43; DOJ explanation for military victims; DOJ Fund FAQ; DOJ final rule announcement; JURIST; Congressional Research Service.

In the talmudic system, nobody asked what the woman or man did for a living, what they earned, or whether they were any good at it. You were sorted by broad identities: gender and age, In the Feinberg system the question was also economic, but it was very much focussed on what the person did for a living, and how much they stood to earn over their life.

Neither system answers what a life is worth. Each answers a narrower question. The Talmud asks what we owe, and it treats a person as a member of a category: age, then sex. The 9/11 Fund asked what a family has lost, and it treated a person as a career. Feinberg later wondered whether paying every eligible family the same would have been better. That is the Talmud’s instinct, arrived at by a very different road.

“Placing a value on life and distributing over $7 billion in public money to 5,562 people - all under the watchful eye of the public, Congress, and the Bush administration - affected my health. It also triggered a reording of my priorities, both personal and professional. If the fund played some role in influencing the future course of the 9/11 families, it also changed my life, I believe for the better. ”
— Kenneth Feinberg. What is Life Worth; The unprecedented effort to compensate the victims of 9/11. Public Affairs 2005. XI
“It was a job that called for the wisdom of Solomon, the technical skill of H&R Block, and the insight of a mystic with a crystal ball.”
— Feinberg, 87.

Bechorot 55a ~ Where Does Your Blood Come From?

בכורות נה, א

אמר רב כהנא כרותא דדמא כבדא

Rav Kahana also states: The source of blood is the liver.

The liver has long been considered a very special organ (as indeed it is). The Babylonians used the organ for divination, as is mentioned in our own Book of Ezekiel (21:26):

כִּי־עָמַד מֶלֶךְ־בָּבֶל אֶל־אֵם הַדֶּרֶךְ בְּרֹאשׁ שְׁנֵי הַדְּרָכִים לִקְסָם־קָסֶם קִלְקַל בַּחִצִּים שָׁאַל בַּתְּרָפִים רָאָה בַּכָּבֵד׃

For the king of Babylon has stood at the fork of the road, where two roads branch off, to perform divination: He has shaken arrows, consulted teraphim, and inspected the liver.

The Greek physician Galen (129-c.207 CE) believed that the liver stored the four humors of the body, and, just like Rav Kahana, he claimed that it produced blood. But both were mistaken

Where your blood actually comes from

Diagram of liver.jpg

Blood is not made in the liver (unless you are a fetus) but in the bone marrow, which is the spongy middle bit of bones. And your bone marrow works really hard. Each day it makes 200,000,000,000 red blood cells, 150,000,000,000 platelet cells, and 20,000,000,000 lymphocytes. It all begins with an all powerful stem cell, which then can turn into (among other things) a red blood cell that carries oxygen and has life of only 120 days), a mast cell which is involved in inflammation and allergies, a neutrophil (also known as a “white blood cell”) which fights infections, or a macrophage, which is a microscopic vacuum cleaner and whose job get rid of all the cellular bits and pieces that don’t belong.

Hematopoiesis_simple.png
“If one considers the annual cumulative cell production, one can calculate a total blood cell production rate of about...88 kg per year ”
— Fliedner T. M et al. Structure and Function of Bone Marrow Hemopoiesis: Mechanisms of Response to Ionizing Radiation Exposure. Cancer Biotherapy and Radiopharmaceuticals 2002; 17 (4) 405-426.

But in The Fetus, the Liver does make blood

In the growing embryo, blood is first made in the yolk sac, but at about 6 weeks gestation the fetal liver takes over. The liver happily churns out all the cells of the blood line, until, at about 5 months gestation, the bone marrow takes over. So neither Rav Kahana nor Galen were totally mistaken when he declared that the source of blood is the liver.

Bechorot 45b ~ Syndactyly

The Cohen with fused digits

Today we continue the discussion of physical abnormalities which would prohibit a Cohen from serving in the Temple. The Mishnah reads as follow:

בכורות לה,ב

אצבעותיו מורכבות זו על זו או קלוטות למעלה עד הפרק כשר למטה מן הפרק וחתכה כשר

A priest whose fingers or toes are configured one upon the other, or one whose fingers or toes are attached, is likewise disqualified. But if they were attached from above the palm of the hand or the bottom of the foot only until the middle joint, he is fit. If they were attached below the joint, higher up on the finger or toe, and he cut to separate them, he is fit. 

The case here is a Cohen with, say two fingers or two toes that are fused together, so that it appears that there is a digit missing. The hand may look like this:

Palm view of classic simple syndactyly of left long and ring fingers. Over 50% of all webbed fingers occur like this.From here.

Palm view of classic simple syndactyly of left long and ring fingers. Over 50% of all webbed fingers occur like this.From here.

maydeletesmaller.jpg

Or in extreme cases like this:

The hand of the patient with syndactyly of several digits. From Biesecker L.G.The Greig cephalopolysyndactyly syndrome. Orphanet Journal of Rare Diseases 2008, 3:10

The hand of the patient with syndactyly of several digits. From Biesecker L.G.The Greig cephalopolysyndactyly syndrome. Orphanet Journal of Rare Diseases 2008, 3:10

These photos are all obviously from young children, which is good news. Surgeons are able to separate the fused fingers or toes, generally when the infant is 1-2 years old, and so there are now few adults around in whom the condition went uncorrected.

The Classification of Syndactyly

Syndactyly (from the Greek syn = together; dactylos=digit) occurs in about 2-3 per 10,000 live births In 10-40% there is a family history of the condition and is twice as common among males (remember these facts for later). In about half of all cases there are bilateral and symmetrical fusions, and while it may be an isolated finding, in many cases it is part of a genetic disorder like Apert’s or Poland’s syndrome.

There are several different types and subtypes, depending on whether the condition is classified based on an anatomical approach, a genetic or molecular approach, a descriptive approach or an embryological classification. One classification, from a 2012 review of the topic published in The European Journal of Human Genetics, is shown below.

Schematic diagrams of syndactyly types (I-a–III). Shaded digits depict cutaneous fusion only, while bony synostosis is represented by black digital elements within the shaded area. The grey digital elements show hypoplastic phalanges or clinodactyly…

Schematic diagrams of syndactyly types (I-a–III). Shaded digits depict cutaneous fusion only, while bony synostosis is represented by black digital elements within the shaded area. The grey digital elements show hypoplastic phalanges or clinodactyly/brachydactyly. The digital elements with amorphous borders symbolize dysplastic bones. From Malik S. Syndactyly: phenotypes, genetics and current classification. European Journal of Human Genetics (2012) 20, 817–824;

What Causes Syndactyly? It’s often the genes

Syndactyly sometimes runs in families, so in these cases a genetic cause was long suspected. For example, fusion of the fourth and fifth metacarpals (an uncommon type of syndactyly) was first described 1928 and was initially thought to have an X-linked recessive trait. It was later classified as an autosomal dominant inheritance, found in some families with male-male transmission as well as females affected. But we are now able to exactly pinpoint some of the genetic causes. Type I, Apert syndrome, is associated with the FGFR2 gene (to be exact the the loci 10q26). Type II, (Carpenter syndrome) is linked to RAB23 gene, and Type V, also known as Pfeiffer syndrome is been linked to the FGFR 1 and 2 genes.

A family with three generations of ring and small finger involvement, none of which was ever surgically corrected. From Flatt A. Webbed Fingers. In The Care of Congenital Hand Anomalies, 2nd ed. St. Louis: Quality Medical Publishing, Inc., 1994:228–…

A family with three generations of ring and small finger involvement, none of which was ever surgically corrected. From Flatt A. Webbed Fingers. In The Care of Congenital Hand Anomalies, 2nd ed. St. Louis: Quality Medical Publishing, Inc., 1994:228–275.

Why did the Mishnah Discuss Syndactyly in Cohanim?

At first, the discussion of syndactyly as a disqualification for a Cohen seems rather odd. I mean really, how many cases could there have been? But the reason that the Mishnah spent time on this is now obvious. In many cases it is a genetic disorder, mostly affecting men. To be a Cohen you must be the child of a father who is a Cohen. As we have already learned, there are several “Cohen related genes,” and now we can add to the list the possibility that one of the many genetic causes of syndactyly was linked to those who were Cohanim, and who might pass the gene to their male children.

As we saw in an earlier post, the rabbis of the Mishnah and Talmud described different medical observations without realising that they originated from a single cause (like alcoholic liver disease) or had a genetic component. How lucky we are to have this knowledge at our fingertips (sorry). The rabbis would have wanted no less.

[Extra credit: The Wiki page on Syndactyly notes that “The earliest appreciation of syndactyly as a birth anomaly…can be traced back to the Andalusian Muslim surgeon Al-Zahrawi (d. 1013 CE).” This should obviously be corrected, since it was mentioned as a birth defect in the Mishnah, edited c. 200 CE, some eight hundred years earlier. Can someone please edit the page so that it is accurate? Thanks.]